Had the studio given more time and resources, "Silent Hill 2" could've been great. But they didn't and it isn't. The script is disastrous and the direction is flat.
In general, "Dredd" is a matter of taste. If the idea of a killing machine (and his rookie partner) plowing through criminals using guns, explosives, fists, psychic powers (!!) and other bizarre weapons sounds intriguing to you, "Dredd" is your movie. Guess what? Just typing that gave me an erection, so this is obviously my kind of joint.